I think your instincts are generally right, Jilayne. I'd add that "incompatible" means different things in different factual situations as well- i.e., how exactly are the materials under license X and

All, We (Tech, Business and Legal chairs along with Phil) have been putting together a roadmap for SPDX. This will cover 2013. The draft can be found here:http://spdx.org/wiki/roadmap-2013 . It

Thanks Roger. We have a legal call tomorrow morning, so we will discuss this on the call. - Jilayne

Oh well, yes, that information is certainly helpful, I would agree! But it involves exactly the kind of legal interpretation that we cannot give. Reasonable attorneys may disagree what is

Dear SPDX Legal Team Just found another license introduced by TIZEN a project hosted by the Linux Foundation. I do not know why another license is needed for this... The license is used within the

* Tieh, Helen <helen.tieh@...> [2012-10-27 00:06]: I've changed your address for spdx and spdx-legal. -- Martin Michlmayr Open Source Program Office, Hewlett-Packard

Hi SPDX, Can you please change my email of record to helenwtieh@...? Thank you! Helen Tieh ------------------------------ Helen Tieh Senior IP Counsel Hewlett-Packard Company 3000

Hi Legal team, Forwarding on a request for an additional column to the table to indicate GPL compatibility. Not sure what your position is on it, but figured would bring it to your

Another lightly-attended meeting… let's do something about this in two weeks!! Minutes posted here: http://spdx.org/wiki/legal-team-meeting-minutes-2012-10-17 Jilayne Lovejoy | Corporate

Tom, I would suggest working with Bradley Khun on this. I recall he had sent several messages on how we might not have exceptions prior to the GPLv3 versions of the compiler and compiler libraries

I am not familiar with the subtleties of the GCC exceptions and am looking for help. The SPDX license list includes a v2 and v3 version of the GCC Runtime Library Exception. These are pasted

We had a small turnout, so just worked on some of the agenda items that I sent yesterday. Please review the meeting minutes here: http://spdx.org/wiki/legal-team-meeting-minutes-2012-10-03 (I hope

HI All, We have a meeting tomorrow morning (Wednesday) at 8am PST / 11 EST – please find the dial in info here: http://spdx.org/content/meeting-calendar-conference-access-1 Please review the

Hi all, I was trying to straighten out a couple of the GPL exceptions and 1) wanted to feedback; and 2) think we may need to update a couple of the full license namesŠ (which I hate to do, but it

Topic: OpenLDAP SPDX License Notes, September 19, 2012, Tom Incorvia;tom.incorvia@...; thomas.incorvia@..., 408 499 6850. Note: ignore prefix numbers in brackets ( “[ ]” ) in the zipped folder

Can be found here: http://spdx.org/content/legal-team-meeting-minutes-2012-09-19 Jilayne Lovejoy | Corporate Counsel OpenLogic, Inc. jlovejoy@... | 720 240 4545

At 9am Mtn Time (8am Pacific // 11am Eastern) Agenda: 1) follow-up on various to-dos from FSF license list additions 2) discussion of freeware and shareware licenses – to add or not to add Dial in:

Topic: OpenLDAP SPDX License Notes, September 19, 2012, Tom Incorvia;tom.incorvia@...; thomas.incorvia@..., 408 499 6850. Note: Ignore the bracketed numbers that prefix the zipped license

<jbuttura@...> wrote: Jason: there is a good reason for this: The use of the V1.0 license was limited to a brief period in time and a long seven years ago. Cases of actual reuse of code under

Hi all, On our last SPDX Legal call, I took two items from the license list for further research: 1) BitTorrent Open Source License 1.1: are there multiple versions of this license, and if so, are the